MailMonitor vs Instantly: Compared Feature-by-Feature

Illustration of an anthropomorphic tiger with orange fur and black stripes, wearing a black shirt. The tiger has a serious expression and crossed arms, set against a light yellow background.
Smiling person with a beard and short hair against a black background, wearing a black top.
A person with long blonde hair is looking at the camera. They are wearing a black top and are indoors, with a neutral expression and soft lighting.
A person with short hair and a beard wearing a patterned shirt stands outdoors with a sunset in the background. The sky is a gradient of blue, orange, and pink, and a body of water is visible in the distance.
Talk with a
deliverability expert!

Content:

    The success of email marketing campaigns heavily relies on high deliverability rates, making email warming an essential practice. This process ensures that your emails consistently reach your audience’s inboxes, avoiding spam filters. In this feature-by-feature comparison, we delve into two prominent SaaS tools in the email deliverability space: MailMonitor and Instantly.

    MailMonitor

    mailmonitor

    MailMonitor emerges as a robust platform compatible with a wide array of email service providers, focusing on enhancing email deliverability. It boasts a user-friendly interface and quick setup, requiring no complex integrations, positioning itself as a straightforward solution for monitoring and optimizing email campaigns. However, it lacks certain features like free tools and blacklist monitoring, which could be pivotal for some businesses.

    Instantly

    Instantly

    Instantly offers a simplistic yet effective approach to email warming, compatible with various email providers. It prides itself on an intuitive interface and one-click solutions that streamline the user experience. Unlike MailMonitor, Instantly integrates with Zapier and provides webhooks for advanced automation, although it also does not offer free tools or blacklist monitoring.

    Email Providers and SMTP Compatibility

    Both MailMonitor and Instantly are designed to work seamlessly across different email service providers, ensuring broad compatibility. This flexibility allows users to integrate these tools into their existing email strategies effortlessly.

    Warm-Up Volume

    MailMonitor does not specify a warm-up volume, suggesting a tailored approach to meet individual user needs. Instantly also does not detail specific warm-up volumes, focusing instead on simplicity and ease of use for their warming processes.

    Ease of Use

    MailMonitor is recognized for its quick setup and user-friendly interface, making it accessible to marketers of all skill levels. Instantly mirrors this approach with its simple and intuitive interface, ensuring a hassle-free experience for users looking to improve their email deliverability.

    Free Tools

    Neither MailMonitor nor Instantly offers free tools for email optimization, focusing their resources on core functionalities to enhance email deliverability.

    Blacklist monitoring

    Both platforms do not provide blacklist monitoring features, a gap that might be critical for users who prioritize comprehensive deliverability solutions.

    API Access

    MailMonitor offers API access, allowing for more sophisticated integration with users’ existing systems. In contrast, Instantly does not provide API access but compensates with Zapier integration and webhooks for advanced automation capabilities.

    Customer Support

    MailMonitor supports its users through email, offering dedicated assistance for any deliverability issues encountered. Instantly extends its customer support to include both chat and email, ensuring a broader range of support options for its users.

    Free Trial and Feedback

    MailMonitor does not offer a free trial, potentially limiting for users who prefer to test services before committing. Instantly, on the other hand, provides a free trial, accompanied by mixed reviews on Trustpilot and high praise on G2.

    Conclusion

    Deciding between MailMonitor and Instantly hinges on specific needs and preferences regarding email deliverability tools. MailMonitor is suited for those seeking a straightforward, integration-friendly solution, while Instantly appeals to users looking for simple, one-click solutions with advanced automation through Zapier.

    For a more comprehensive solution, Warmy.io stands out by offering the largest volume of warm-up emails per day (2000), an array of features, the deepest free email deliverability test, and numerous free tools. With exceptional support and advanced email deliverability capabilities, Warmy.io is designed to meet and exceed the needs of businesses aiming for top-tier inbox placement rates. Explore Warmy.io to leverage unmatched advantages in your email strategy, ensuring your communications not only reach your audience but also drive meaningful engagement.

    Picture of Daniel Shnaider

    Article by

    Daniel Shnaider

    Picture of Daniel Shnaider

    Article by

    Daniel Shnaider

    An icon depicting a closed white envelope resting in an open, empty white tray with a blue interior background.

    Get the week’s
    best marketing content

      *You can unsubscribe anytime
      An icon depicting a closed white envelope resting in an open, empty white tray with a blue interior background.

      Get the week’s
      best marketing content

        *You can unsubscribe anytime

        Ensure your email success

        Reach More Inboxes and Drive Results!

        Mailbox Temperature

        500 /day

        Related Post

        The Simple Mail Transfer Protocol (SMTP)’s primary role is to make sure messages take the right path from senders to

        While email marketing plays a key role in brand building, it has become more challenging than ever. Emails may go

        In 2024, the number of sent and received emails reached 361.5 billion. Can you believe it? And this 2025, it

        Can you remember the last thing you wanted to buy? Take a minute to think back to the moment leading

        Scroll to Top